2024 Kaedrin Movie Awards: The Arbitrary Awards
The 2024 Kaedrin Movie Awards Winners were announced last week, which means that it’s time for more… arbitrary considerations. The idea is to recognize aspects of films that aren’t reflected in more traditional awards or other praise like a Top 10 list. However, any consistent, formal awards system will fail to capture all the nuances and complexity available; hence the 2024 Arbitrary Awards, an opportunity to commend movies that are weird or flawed in ways that don’t conform to normal standards. A few of these “awards” have become an annual tradition, some were stolen from other folks, but most are just, well, arbitrary. Previous Arbitrary Awards: [2023 | 2022 | 2021 | 2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006]
The “You know what happens when a toad gets struck by lightning? The same thing that happens to everything else” Award for Worst Dialogue: Madame Web. The most infamous line, “He was in the Amazon with my mom when she was researching spiders right before she died” is kinda perfect, and Dakota Johnson’s delivery just nails it. Plenty of other bad dialogue, including this banger “When you take on the responsibility, great power will come.” It’s hilarious how many Spider (and Spider-adjacent) movies have tried to do a spin on “With great power comes great responsibility” but botch it so thoroughly. Anywho, I somehow managed to avoid a lot of the more famously bad dialogue of the year (for example, the other Sony Spider-adjacent movie Kraven the Hunter). One that I did see that I’m a bit torn on is Megalopolis, which has plenty of bad lines, but at least the actors are really going for it (most of what comes out of Adam Driver’s mouth would not work at all coming from another actor). Also, it feels a little like cheating to talk about stuff like Hot Frosty for an award like this, even though it is eminently qualified. So we’ll just stick with Madame Web here. Dialogue that’s so bad it almost rebounds into good.
The Proximity to Jason Voorhees Award for Heroic Stupidity: Alien: Romulus. So much stupid in this movie, and indeed, some of the callbacks to previous films are absolutely hideous (the worst of which, a play on the “Get away from her, you bitch” line, could easily qualify for the previous worst dialogue award).
The Garth Marenghi “I know writers who use subtext, and they’re all cowards” Award for Achievement in Didacticism: The Brutalist. The first half of the movie is actually a pretty good exploration of post-war Jewish assimilation mixed with a mostly subtle portrayal of the conflict between art and commerce. The second half of the film surfaces all of the subtext and ends with a literal lecture, didactically explaining what happened in the movie.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0eb1a/0eb1a6a2e5110691776b438e569cb3c7659f41b1" alt="The Brutalist"
Making the subtext into text isn’t necessarily the worst thing in the world, and this movie has plenty of ardent fans, but I found it to be a bit of an eye rolling experience. It’s far from the worst recipient of this semi-regular arbitrary award, but it’s still a worthy recipient.
Spoilerific Twin Movie Phenomenon of the Year: I suppose even mentioning this is a spoiler, but both Lowlifes and Get Away rely on the exact same twist. It’s a fine twist, but I will admit that the second one I watched fell a bit short simply because I’d already seen something like it (though I did chuckle a bit at the unexpected coincidence).
Least Cathartic Documentary of the Year: Brats. What a bizarre movie. Director Andrew McCarthy was a tertiary member of what became known as the Brat Pack, a group of young stars in the 1980s who struggled somewhat with the label. Or, at least, McCarthy did, and clearly still does, blaming it for much of his career woes. Here, he goes around interviewing other members of the Brat pack, most of whom actively question the premise of the movie right to his face and absolutely refuse to provide McCarthy with any sense of the catharsis he so clearly seeks. It’s like McCarthy discovered a new form of Cringe.
The Quentin Tarantino Pressure Cooker Award: The Last Stop in Yuma County. Tarantino will do this thing where he collects a bunch of characters into an almost claustrophobic space, then uses dialogue to ratchet the tension up and up until the scene explodes into a usually violent climax. Sometimes he’ll center the entire movie on this sort of thing (a la Reservoir Dogs or The Hateful Eight), sometimes it’s just a sequence in a larger narrative (most notably with Inglourious Basterds, but he does it in several others as well).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a2a7b/a2a7b7d352499b32fa28e468fd81b41a5ed21daf" alt="The Last Stop in Yuma County"
Lots of folks have tried imitating this sort of thing, but few are as successful as The Last Stop in Yuma County, which is excellent (perhaps not as punchy as Tarantino, but still) and well worth seeking out. I’d say that Francis Galluppi is a writer/director to look out for, but his next film appears to be an “Untitled Evil Dead Project” which is something I could not be less interested in, so here’s to hoping he gets to make something of his own again soon.
Most Underseen Romantic Comedy: Fly Me to the Moon. I’m a sucker for anything set during the space race, and this movie is cute, but judging from the box office, no one saw it. Worth a watch!
Achievement in the Field of Gratuitous Violence: Terrifier 3. Say what you will about these movies, but they certainly contain copious amounts of gnarly, gratuitous violence.
The “Futurama” Award for Best Science Fiction Comedy: Molli and Max in the Future. It’s basically a live-action Futurama movie with lots of goofy SF-based concepts and plenty of laughs. It shades a bit too topical (it’s sometimes hard to predict what will feel dated in the future, but I feel like this is a movie that is just very 2024).
Best YouTube Release: The Spectacular Failure of the Star Wars Hotel. It’s a four hour long video about Jenny Nicholson’s visit to the now-defunct Star Wars Hotel that is somehow riveting. And it perfectly illustrates why the Star Wars Hotel failed so spectacularly. Whatever you may think of Nicholson, she was 100% onboard with the idea of the theme hotel. This isn’t cynical, bad faith criticism. She loves theme parks, she clearly went into this hoping to engage with the concept, but the hotel experience thwarts her at every turn. It’s not exactly cinema in any real sense, but it perfectly encapsulates the sort of thing YouTube is for.
Just Missed the Cutoff for the Formal Awards: Even though the awards started a few weeks ago, I’ve still been watching movies since the original nominees came out, and some of them were pretty good! Good enough to be nominees, though probably not winners. So take a bow, Exhuma and Oddity (Best Horror), What You Wish For (Best Twist, maybe Best High Concept or Best Horror too), and Here (Best High Concept). All worth watching!
Should Host the Oscars: Monstro Elisasue from The Substance. I mean, it’s no New Year’s Eve hosting event, but I think it’ll do. The longlist: Wow Platinum from Megalopolis, the Octoboss from Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga, Abraxas from Late Night with the Devil, the sentient ravioli from Unfrosted, Longlegs from… Longlegs, Art the Clown from Terrifier 3, Count Orlok from Nosferatu, Moebius from Molli and Max in the Future, Gorcha, and the Vourdalak puppet from The Vourdalak. A solid list, but you really just have to give it to Monstro Elisasue. She was literally made for hosting events like this!
Congrats to all the 2024 Arbitrary Awards winners, stay tuned for moar 2024 movie news, including the traditional top 10 list (probably in a couple weeks) and the usual Oscar commentary.