The 2013 Egg Nog Tasting

A tradition born by accident, my family’s Egg Nog tasting happens every Thanksgiving. One Thanksgiving many moons ago, thanks to poor coordination, everyone brought one or two Egg Nogs, and thus we ended up with, like, 14 different types. I’m not actually positive what year this really went into overdrive, but ever since that fateful year, we’ve actually planned to have that many Egg Nogs, and have even gone so far as to orchestrate a double blind tasting in order to determine the Best Egg Nog (the “worst” is usually a pretty easy and uncontroversial decision that does not require any real debate). I mean, we’re not scientists here or anything, but this is pretty rigorous for a family gathering. I could have sworn I did a better job recapping each year’s proceedings, but only a few previous tastings have been chronicled: [2012 | 2010 | 2008].

One thing we’ve noticed is that the same Egg Nogs tend to show up every year, and we’ve got a few that consistently win (notably local mainstays Wawa and Swiss Farms). Last year we made a rule that the previous year’s winner (and “winner” of worst nog) could not return. This year we made a concerted effort to seek out completely new and obscure Egg Nogs. I was actually shocked at how well we did in this mission, though of course there were a couple repeats. So let’s do this, the Egg Nogs of 2013:

2013 Egg Nogs

For posterity, the Egg Nogs pictured here are (from left to right):

  • Turkey Hill Egg Nog
  • America’s Choice Holiday Favorite Egg Nog
  • Bolthouse Farms Limited Edition Holiday Nog (Low Fat)
  • Promised Land Old Fashioned Egg Nog
  • Trader Joes Egg Nog
  • Trickling Springs Creamery Farm Friend Fresh Egg Nog
  • Califa Farms Almondmilk Holiday Nog
  • Lehigh Valley Holiday Eggnog
  • Borden Eggnog
  • Silk Seasonal Nog

The only returning contenders were the Turkey Hill, which has pretty much always shown up (but always places somewhere in the middle of the pack), and the Silk Seasonal Nog (which has won “worst” in the past). The Borden was arguably a returning contender as well, though it’s now packaged in a resealable container (Borden was always famous for being canned) and while they claim the recipe is the same, this stuff was nothing like the Borden of years past (which was also a middle of the pack performer). Indeed, the Borden was nearly toxic and came out a weirdly bright, almost glowing color. Gross.

But as bad as it was, Borden was still at least marginally identifiable as Egg Nog. One thing I’ve noticed about the competition for worst egg nog is that it is dominated by entries that aren’t actually “egg” nog. They’re always just “Holiday Nog” or “Seasonal Nog” or “Coconut Nog” or some such lie. These really aren’t Egg Nogs, but they’ve got some nutmeg and they’re trying to capitalize on the season. I guess that’s fine for big Soymilk fans, but when you have these right next to real Egg Nog, that just makes them seem all the worse. This year’s competition was between the Bolthouse Farms Low Fat Holiday Nog, which was packaged so deceptively that we didn’t realize what it was until we nearly gagged on it. Silk was its normal self, but the real revolution in bad flavor belongs to Califa Farms Almondmilk Holiday Nog. It was so bad, I think it somehow hurt my eyeballs. The decision was unanimous.

The competition for best was a little better, though I do think the champions of years past (Wawa, Swiss Farms, Upstate Farms) would have trounced all of this year’s competitors. Indeed, the normally middle of the pack Turkey Hill was a clear favorite heading into the blind tasting, which only featured three Egg Nogs this year: Turkey Hill, America’s Choice (whose box sez “fa-la-la-la-yum”, which became its unofficial name), and Promised Land (whose label proclaims “From the finest Jersey Cows”). It was close, but Promised Land came out the victor.

Egg Nogs

It was a fine year, but I think we need to have something like a Tournament of Champions next year, and bring back all the best Egg Nogs. I’m also toying with a rule that we should not accept “holiday nogs” that are not actually Egg Nog. Of course, that would limit options for the “worst” award, though I suppose “Light” egg nogs (or Borden!) could qualify. But maybe instead of worst, we bring back “flavored” egg nogs (which were banned several years ago). We’ll have to wait until next year. But me, I’m going to hit up Wawa sometime this week and get some real Egg Nog…

3 thoughts on “The 2013 Egg Nog Tasting”

  1. It’s too bad many dairy co-ops are regional. Up here in Minnesota, Kemp’s and Land O’ Lakes are the big egg nog producers. Kemp’s even has a deal with an apothecary, J.R. Watkins (, to make nogs with their spices included. The result, a vanilla, vanilla almond, and a pumpkin spice egg nog that are quite excellent. And out of Illinois is the the Oberweis Dairy which produces an Egg Nog in glass bottles, that is the cream of the crop! And Horizon makes an organic egg nog that I believe has a wide distribution.

    Then there are egg nogs premixed with liquor, though the only one I’m aware of is Pennsylvania Dutch.

    Point is, so many nogs, so little time!

  2. I agree! After about a decade of eggnog tasting, I’m kinda surprised that we’ve managed to discover so many new and different varieties in just this area. I would imagine the Midwest farmers make wicked Egg Nog. But I also imagine that dairy does not travel well, or that if it did, it’d be so loaded with preservatives and stuff that it’d be a poor substitute. On the other hand, I wonder how national brands like Southern Comfort manage it (do they contract out to regional dairy co-ops?)

    We’ve never gotten much into the liquor egg nogs, nor have we really tried making our own (which I suppose is a possibility, though I’d be scared of inadvertently making my family members sick or something if I did it wrong). You might see that as a lack of ambition on our part, but it’s really just an opportunity in disguise. I’m sure I can take worst in show next year if I put my mind to it!

  3. I feel like I need to do some work on west coast egg nogs and get in on this. I love me some egg nog. I can’t imagine any “holiday nog” making the cut.

    I had rum and egg nog at a holiday party for possibly the first time a few weeks ago. Pretty good actually. I went easy on the rum so it didn’t overpower the egg noggy nogness.

Comments are closed.