- Best Novel has some interesting meta-characteristics. In terms of genre, we've got half science fiction, half fantasy (though at least one of the ones I'm counting as SF appears to be more of a mixture of SF and fantasy, and in looking further, one of the fantasy seems to have SF elements). Only two novels are part of a series, and they're both the first in the series (and, one hopes, could operate well enough as a standalone read). Fully half of the nominees are first novels, though at least one of those authors has previously won a Hugo in a short fiction category... All of the nominees are written by women and this is, to my knowledge, the first time this has ever happened (though it was inevitable given the past few years; by my count women authors have outnumbered men 21-8 in the past 5 years, even if men have historically taken the cake). This is also the first time in a decade that I haven't read any of the finalists before they were announced.
- Of the nominated novels, I have already started Arkady Martine's A Memory Called Empire and am enjoying it so far (I'm only about a third of the way through). Of the nominees, this was the one that was on my radar but for some reason I never caught up with it. I've not read a ton of Seanan McGuire (aka Mira Grant), but I've generally enjoyed her work, which has been nominated quite a bit over the last decade or so, and Middlegame sounds fun. Alix E. Harrow won last year's Hugo for Short Story (and it was my favorite of the nominees), so I'm curious to see if she can translate that success to novel size with The Ten Thousand Doors of January. Gideon the Ninth appears to be Tamsyn Muir's debut, and it sounds like a fun fantasy in space. I've been mixed on Charlie Jane Anders in the past. On the one hand, I nominated her short story a few years back. On the other hand, I was more mixed on All the Birds in the Sky, which has a nice whimsical tone, but the mixture of SF and fantasy didn't quite work for me. Her new novel, The City in the Middle of the Night, sounds similar to that. Finally, The Light Brigade by Kameron Hurley appears to be military SF, but I haven't particularly loved Hurley's work in the past. Every year, I wonder if I should keep participating. This shortlist looks decent in comparison to last year, but it's pretty heavily focused on fantasy, and even the SF seems less like my particular cup of tea. Then again, current circumstances have conspired to give me extra reading time and I'm actually looking forward to a couple of the fantasy stories, so perhaps I'll soldier on.
- In the shorter fiction categories, I see that two Ted Chiang stories from Exhalation made the list. I foolishly saw the publication history page of that book and didn't realize that not all the stories were listed (i.e. I thought all the stories in that collection were previously published, but a couple were new and thus eligible). Of the two nominated stories, I really liked the novella "Anxiety Is the Dizziness of Freedom". I actually recognize a couple of the other novellas, but the rest of the pack is new to me, though most of the authors have been nominated before.
- Best Dramatic Presentation, Long Form continues to befuddle me. On the one hand, I like the nomination of Us. On the on the other hand, how on earth does Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker make the list? Marvel movies always make the cut, but even this crop seems a bit weak. Also? Two different tv seasons were nominated? What's going on here? Anyway, pour one out for Prospect and The Kid Who Would Be King, both worthy of your attention (and better and far more interesting than the likes of The Rise of Skywalker).
- In an unusual twist, I've already seen 4 of the 6 nominees for Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form. But the question remains: if Watchmen was good enough to garner two nominations in the short form category, why weren't people nominating it for long form? What criteria are people using to determine when a series should be rewarded in short form vs long form?
- The 1945 Retro Hugo Award finalists were also announced last week. The thing that jumped out at me the most was Theodore Sturgeon's novella "Killdozer!" which is about exactly what you think it's about. Best Dramatic Presentation has the usual smattering of Universal monsters and RKO horror, but a couple other interesting nominees that I might have to check out...
Hugo Awards 2020: Initial Thoughts
The 2020 Hugo Award Finalists were announced earlier this week, so it's time for the requisite whinging: